There is something fascinating about how companies recruit their next CEO.
They spend months discussing the future. They talk about transformation, growth, innovation and the next chapter.
Then someone walks into the room with a familiar name, an impressive title and three previous CEO appointments.
Suddenly, everybody feels a little more comfortable.
Experience matters, of course.
But here's the uncomfortable question:
Are you recruiting the person who successfully ran somebody else's business yesterday, or the person capable of leading yours tomorrow?
Those aren't necessarily the same thing.
The CEO recruitment market is changing.
According to Russell Reynolds Associates' Global CEO Turnover Index, 234 CEOs departed their positions across the tracked listed-company indices in 2025.
That was a 16% increase from the previous year.
Perhaps more interestingly, 86% of incoming CEOs were first-time public-company CEOs.
The assumption that the safest CEO appointment is someone who has already held exactly that title doesn't reflect the whole market.
Spencer Stuart's European research tells another interesting story.
Of the CEO appointments it tracked across major European listed companies in 2025, 56% were external appointments. Yet among companies valued above $20 billion that changed CEO, approximately two-thirds selected an internal successor.
These figures describe different groups of companies, but together they reinforce an important point: there isn't one universally correct route to finding the next CEO.
The context matters.
Mistake one: Starting with a person instead of a strategy.
Perhaps the current CEO is excellent at managing an established business.
But the next five years might require something completely different.
A company preparing for international expansion may need somebody with demonstrated market-building experience.
A technology business entering a period of restructuring could need someone capable of making difficult operational decisions.
A founder-led company appointing its first external CEO faces another challenge entirely: finding a leader who can establish authority while working constructively with the founder.
Before writing a CEO job description, the board should be able to answer:
What must this business become over the next three to five years—and what kind of leadership will make that possible?
Without that clarity, even a rigorous recruitment process can end up assessing candidates against yesterday's requirements.
Mistake two: Treating succession planning like an emergency.
If the first serious conversation about succession happens when the current CEO announces their departure, the board is already under pressure.
Potential internal successors may not have had time to develop the experience needed for the role.
External candidates may be poorly understood.
And the business could end up making a rushed decision simply to remove uncertainty.
McKinsey's work on succession planning argues for an ongoing, structured process rather than a reactive response to an unexpected vacancy.
We agree with the underlying principle.
Leadership planning should happen while things are going well—not only when something has gone wrong.
Mistake three: Confusing familiarity with suitability.
Internal candidates have valuable organisational knowledge. They understand the people, culture, systems and history.
External candidates may bring capabilities, networks and fresh perspectives that the company doesn't currently possess.
Neither is automatically superior.
A good search should assess both options against the same future-facing leadership requirements.
That means asking for evidence of decision-making, commercial judgement, people leadership, change management and the ability to execute strategy.
Not simply asking who has held the most prestigious previous position.
Mistake four: Forgetting that the candidate is evaluating you, too.
An exceptional CEO candidate isn't just choosing a job.
They're evaluating the board, the company's financial position, its strategic clarity, its stakeholders and how much authority they will actually have.
A business may be looking for transformational leadership while remaining unwilling to change anything.
That contradiction will eventually become apparent.
The recruitment process should create space for both sides to examine expectations openly.
A successful appointment requires more than identifying someone qualified. It requires agreement about the actual job they're being asked to do.
Four questions every board should ask
Before beginning the next CEO search, we'd put these questions on the table:
1. What will success look like three years after this appointment? 2. Which capabilities are genuinely missing from our current leadership? 3. Have we objectively assessed internal and external candidates? 4. Are we prepared to give the incoming CEO the authority and support needed to succeed?
If the answers aren't clear, perhaps the recruitment brief isn't ready.
Strengthen your board and advisory expertise.
We help organisations define their board and advisory needs and connect with relevant board members, chairs and advisors.
Sources & further reading
Russell Reynolds' 2025 turnover index provides the global appointment figures, while Spencer Stuart provides the European findings, including the distinction between internal and external appointments. McKinsey supports treating succession as a continuing strategic process.
